About $195 to $287 as of 2026-11-09, based on 3 recent eBay sales with a median of $230. Similar ones are listed right now for $140 to $300, but asking prices run higher than what things sell for.
Recent eBay sales: $229 (Vintage 4 Pyrex Amish Butterprint Cinderella Nesting Bowls Turquoise…); $230 (Vintage Pyrex Amish Butterprint Turquoise 4pc Nesting Bowl Set 401…); $309 (Vintage Pyrex Amish Butterprint Cinderella Mixing Bowls Set Turquoise…).
For Pyrex and similar glass: the exact pattern and color, and how much the color has faded (dishwasher wear), drive the price. Chips, cracks and crazing lower the value a lot. Complete sets sell for more than the bowls one at a time. For cast iron: the maker's mark and logo style (a Griswold large block logo, for example) and the size number set the market.
More on kitchen and cookware prices
Snap 2–4 photos and Guestimator prices yours from what's selling now, then lists it on your own eBay account. You check every word first.
Guestimate mineGuestimates are market estimates from public eBay data at the date shown, not certified appraisals. Prices change; check before you buy or sell. As an eBay Partner, Guestimator may be paid a commission when you buy through links on this page.